There were many interesting things about his story, and his photos are as evocative as they sounded in the interview. But I was struck by a couple of things. First of all, Johnson did not remain a photographer throughout his life. He's in his 80s now, and his wife described how she never knew he had been a photographer until after an archivist sought out his work for a show of the Golden Era. In order to help him write his books, she read through his journals spanning back through his life, and learned all these things about him. He grew up in segregated Florida, fought in the Philippines in WWII, came to SF to study photography and eventually moved back to Florida. Now there is a documentary and book about his work, and his photos capture a particular viewpoint of SF at a particular time in history.
A few weeks ago, my father sent me a copy of a letter that his father had written to his mother a few days after V-J Day. My grandfather had returned from the North Africa (where he served in the Army) and was living temporarily at Camp Pinedale CA before returning home. In the letter, he tells of agreeing to go into San Francisco with a buddy of his. As it turns out, it is V-J Day. Here's what he writes:
We went to San Francisco and it was nothing new for me it was just like any other city. And for a Sunday and V-J Day it sure was quiet. For one thing all the "Beer-joints" were closed. But we did enjoy the ride up to 'Frisco and back. We went up on the streamliner and we did a little venture trip and Hitch-Hiked back. and saw some of this country. I guess I saw enough included the Pacific Ocean. So I guess I am all set to come home.This account leaves me feeling so empty. I cannot imagine being in San Francisco on V-J Day and not feeling like I was living a moment of history. Why was it quiet? Where might there be celebration? And to see California in a day or two and be ready to be done with it? Baffling to me.
One of these men could describe, in 2013, the feeling of getting off the bus in SF in 1945 or 1948 and make me feel and understand how it was to live in that moment. And then, on top of it, he created beautiful pictures that verify his account of that moment. The other man not only couldn't describe what was happening in a very important historical moment at the time it was happening, he didn't even seem like he could experience that moment at all.
I spent a lot of the rest of the day thinking about this contrast, and how clarifying it was for me about who I want to be. I want to experience moments, create them, describe them. Leave a record so that my children can look back on it and understand what it meant to be in that moment, and cause them to think on their own moments, and cause them to want to impact history somehow.